CONTRADICTORY HADITHS
As we have seen, God says that the Quran is protected and free from all contradictions. God brings testimony to His statement by the fact that the Quran is His own word. By analogy, we deduced in Chapter 6 that hadiths could not constitute a source for religion as they clashed even with the Quran. These discrepancies are proofs of our contention. We shall be witnessing the fact that truth and falsehood are inextricably mixed together. It would be worth while to note that even though, when a given hadith does not conflict with the Quran and is not contrary to reason, it does not necessarily follow that it is the word of the Prophet and need not be taken as such. Religion cannot be based on such conjectures. Therefore no hadith can be considered having a religious connotation.
116 – If you obey the majority of people on earth, they will divert you from the path of God. They follow only conjecture, they only guess.
6 The Cattle, 116
36 – Most of them follow nothing but conjecture. Surely, conjecture is no substitute for the truth. God is fully aware of everything they do. But most of them follow nothing but fancy: truly fancy can be of no avail against truth. Verily God is well aware of all they do.
10 Jonah, 36
We are warned against abiding by conjectures. To try to found religious concepts on conjectures like hadiths would be baseless, since we have been provided with a miraculous, guarded and sound source without any contradiction like the Quran. Now we are going to illustrate the incongruity between hadiths in 10 examples.
PAGE 2: 1) DRAWING BLOOD DURING FAST
PAGE 3: 2) TURNING TOWARD MECCA DURING URINATION OR DEFECATION
PAGE 4: 3) KISSING ONE’S WIFE DOES NOT VIOLATE ONE’S FAST
PAGE 5: 4) CAN ONE PERFORM THE SALAT (RITUAL PRAYER) TWICE?
PAGE 6: 5) URINATING
PAGE 7: 6) DRINKING WATER
PAGE 8: 7) MENSTRUAL PERIOD
PAGE 9: 8.) CAN SOMEONE ON PILGRIMAGE GET MARRIED?
PAGE 10: 9) CAN A MAN’S CALF BE UNCOVERED?
PAGE 11: 10) THE SKIN OF DEAD ANIMAL
